My sister Nancy makes a valid point in her comment to my last post ... it's not appropriate to restrict graphic software to use only by industry professionals. Not in this day and age of do-it-yourself everything. I have mixed thoughts about this trend.
I like very much that there are tools available independent artists like Felicia Day and Projected Twin to bypass the big studio entertainment business blockades. They can create and distribute their own creative work, gather their own audience, and stay in direct contact with them at the same time. The tools are getting more sophisticated, and while "The Guild" may never have the special effects of a Speilberg blockbuster... it doesn't need to. It's great and it's out there, and it's not by Paramount or 20th Century Fox or Tristar. Yay all over that.
On a smaller scale, there's a self-checkout at the library, and at the grocery store, and of course the gas station... do your own taxes online... ok, still good...
How about going to WebMD to self-diagnose? How about going to one of these online trading sites to pick some investments? There are lines drawn for things that can affect your health, like purchasing certain medications, but there are many other things that you get to do all by your own little ole self, whether you are able to make wise and informed choices or not. Granted, you're not going to lose your savings or your health if you choose to create a jpg when you really need a gif; I'm just wondering at what point it becomes more problematic than convenient to do it all yourself?
Yes, this is an extremely silly comparison. I bring it up as two points on a wider scale. Maybe there should be a scale of 1 to 10, where sewing on your own button is a 1 and doing your own appendectomy is a 10.
2 comments:
Well said! I think the line between DIY and hiring someone is a very fuzzy individual thing. Dad was a big fan of DIY and pretty good at it too. He mostly knew his limits, and he bartered with friends who were good at various things. A lot of people really can't tell the difference between a mediocre amateur effort and a polished professional effort. If you have more money than time or talent, and if results have to be your very best (or you need an appendectomy!), then hire a professional.
I keep thinking about the running gag on the old Cosby show -- Bill was convinced that he never needed to spend money on a professional plumber or other contractor, would take on a repair task himself. Hilarity and dampness would ensue. I guess it's good that people want to try things on their own, but there sure are messes to clean up afterwards. I get annoyed when people don't understand enough about the project to know that they HAVE created a mess.
Post a Comment